The founder's policy chapter

FINCLUDE INSIGHTS / 2017

Digital Financial Services: Pakistan Landscape of 2025

Industry stakeholders' vision & ideation workshop · Pakistan's first LEGO® SERIOUS PLAY® gamification for DFS · 2017

Sponsored by Karandaaz Digital

Delivered by Finclude with Innoventures

LEGO® SERIOUS PLAY® facilitator Hassan Bin Rizwan

Digital Financial Services- Pakistan Landscape of 2025

Industry Stake holders Vision & Ideation Workshop

Pakistan’s first LEGO® SERIOUS PLAY® gamification for Digital Financial Services

Karandaaz Introduction

Karandaaz is a not-for-profit development finance company established in 2014 and registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP). The organization promotes access to finance for small businesses through commercially directed investments, and financial inclusion for individuals by employing technology-enabled digital solutions.

Karandaaz Digital is the Karandaaz program vertical that focuses on expanding access to digital financial services in Pakistan. It works across the ecosystem with all stakeholders including regulators, policymakers, government departments, businesses, researchers and academics.

Workshop Background

Karandaaz Digital sponsored a 2day DFS Ideation workshop to engage with the industry stake holders to gain insights about their perspectives of the DFS Ecosystem and its growth challenges and challenging them with imagining the DFS eco system of Pakistan in 2025.

Innoventures Private Limited and Finclude Pakistan collaborated to conduct the 2 day workshop aggregating the renowned DFS industry veterans, fintech professionals, regulator representatives and Pakistan’s first LEGO® SERIOUS PLAY® (LSP) certified professional, Hassan Bin Rizwan to introduce LSP for the design ideation of DFS for the first time in Pakistan.

Day 1 was reserved to build the understanding of the functioning of the existing DFS landscape. The role of the market players, banks, non-banking financial service providers, PSPs, Fintechs and regulators.

Day 2 built on the previous day’s training of technology, operations and regulatory framework, during which Pakistan’s existing providers and enablers were introduced. An insight into domestic market opportunities was provided considering the global DFS trend. Participants gained insights about the role of the market forces in today’s landscape that formed the basis to envision the role of demand and supply players of 2025.The session concluded with Pakistan’s first DFS gamification exercise using LEGO® SERIOUS PLAY® (https://www.LEGO®.com/en-us/seriousplay ) conducted by Pakistan’s first certified trainer Hassan Bin Rizwan.

Using the LEGO® SERIOUS PLAY® the attendees were encouraged to collaboratively think and brainstorm ideas as they envision the DFS landscape in 2025.

The undermentioned describes the methodology and the insights gained from the exercise. This is shared with the industry stake holders and thought leaders to help converge thoughts and developing the industry goals for 2025 for a collective benefit of the ecosystem

Methodology

To emulate the functioning of a DFS ecosystem, three groups were created role playing the market forces representing Demand and Supply side.

Demand Side Representation

Mass market Customers – how the base of the pyramid & financially excluded people would use Digital Financial Services offering and the challenges that they face in their day to day work

Supply Side Representation

1. Financial institutions – how traditional financial institutions can leverage the use of DFS into their work, enhancing their systems

2. Non-Banking financial institution – how non-banking financial institutions, Fintechs, are benefiting from DFS

Kickoff

Hassan Bin Rizwan, who conducted the exercise, explained the purpose of the workshop, further elaborating on constructivism. The facilitator elaborated on instructions and discussed the four steps of LEGO® SERIOUS PLAY® by stating that each group will get a challenge, time to build their model, time to share the model and answer questions about their model.

This was followed by the initial playful exercises to make the audience indulge with the LEGO® blocks.

The first task of the LEGO® SERIOUS PLAY® was to build a tower using the blocks which stands on its own. After successful completion of the first task, it was established that each individual has their own critical mind and there is no duplication of ideas as none of the towers looked alike.

The second task of the LEGO® SERIOUS PLAY® allowed the participants to create their version of the worst mothers-in-law, using the LEGO® Players. This propelled the participants into expressing their ideas in various shapes and forms, as many negative aspects were highlighted through this play.

After the initial exercise the participating teams started working on the DFS landscape and were instructed to create their version of the products, services and the existing DFS landscape.

DFS Current Landscaping & Challenges

Supply Side Insights

NBFI (Non-Banking Financial Institutions) perspective

After the allotted time the group participants summarized their models as follows:

The first participant hailing from a telecom company explained that his model represented the scale and reach of his network as it was catering to the needs of the entire country. As one of the largest telecom operator in the country his model depicted its success in offering services in the remote areas of Pakistan where other providers had not been able to extend their reach yet.

The second model was based on a courier company that offers services over a vast area with the facility to make payments, place orders and get products delivered through an online mobile app.

The participant from Pakistan Post used the analogy of a turtle for his company portraying slow delivery and inefficiency in the delivery system. He noted that DFS is an elephant in the room depicting his apprehensions on whether it will be able to deliver to its consumers.

Another participant’s model highlighted the fact that Easy paisa is a major player in the DFS market. He noted that entities such as the state bank is proving to be a barrier.

At the close of this activity the participants were asked to use individual models to create a shared model which reflects the applicability of DFS in present times. The facilitator invited other teams to join in, one team member eloquently described the shared model to all present. He made the following observations:

Most of the network providers are operating in silos, there isn’t a single provider that offers connectivity in all the four provinces.

The Telecom sector extended its connectivity to all the players and some of the barriers got removed opening up doors for new startups and programs.

Although the barriers have been evaded there is still some fierce competition between TCS and Pakistan Post because they have overlapping services and products.

It was concluded that connectivity created an enabling environment for all the players in the market helping them to reach their customers via a common ecosystem.

The following challenges came to light after the participants were asked to build smaller individual models showing obstacles, challenges and hurdles for the non-financial institutions in the DFS landscape.

The telecom sector in its efforts to connect customers with merchants through a monetary bridge is facing difficulties due to regulatory issues.

The IT sector is out dated its infrastructure needs to be revamped.

Our ecosystem is under developed where in a single entity by means of unfair strategies has captured the entire market restricting the entry of others. This will negatively impact the broader market in the long run.

Banking Institutions perspective

This group was assigned the Financial Institutions and explained its perspective on how DFS is currently being used in the industry. The participants were allotted time and came up with the following scenarios with reference to how DFS is perceived in financial institutions in today’s world. Using LEGO® models, the participants expressed the following views:

DFS is actively being used in mobile payments as money is being transferred between banks and the customers; the funds are flowing both ways enhancing connectivity and smooth flow.

An online banking system was depicted in the second model where bankers and customers used internet banking to conduct daily transactions through easily accessible portals.

The third model depicted an existing bank, trying to move towards DFS; rapidly transforming through enhanced telecommunications and use of technology.

The use of agriculture related banking products which banks offer through digital access.

Another model depicted workers in remote areas accepting remittances through communication channels established by DFS.

The last model depicted legacy banks, opening up various opportunities to make money while failing to utilize means of DFS properly due to lack of capacity to enhance their overall productivity.

This activity led to the observation that there has been a move from traditional banking as new technology is being introduced, even though the process seems to be slow. It was also observed that all the players are facing a lack of connectivity and do not have the means of embracing new technology. Communication barriers still exist despite the prevalence of multiple telecoms spread widely across the country.

After describing the individual models, the participants were asked to join their models and create a scenario which reflects the use of DFS in today’s financial banking systems. The following scenarios emerged:

Despite the fact that the banking systems have the desire to integrate DFS, there is limited potential to utilize it properly. This is due to fact that there are a variety of users including customers from agriculture based economies, who have not been reached yet. There is a mental block that the banks face in terms of how this technology can be used; how more customers can be reached thus making the system less effective.

Another scenario presented by the group focused on the traditional banks’ desire to shift to DFS. To cater to this, legacy banks increase their resources, invest in communications and increase their market share to promote efficient banking systems. Traditional institutions still face barriers as to how the technology can be incorporated but inclusion of DFS promotes a greater market penetration and a larger customer base.

While discussing the obstacles, challenges and reasons why the financial industry is not building on DFS, the following challenges were highlighted:

Internal staff is reluctant in terms of accepting DFS changes initiated by the banks. Due to this resistance, the service providers are not giving the customers information regarding the new programs and products based on technological advancements.

Banks work hard to maintain the status quo and avoid implementation of changes with reference to technology to serve their own interests.

Cost of change from traditional banking to DFS is quite high and resources would be mismanaged if such a huge change is mismanaged.

Fear of failing and adopting new technology, as traditional banks are rigid in their management systems and making such a drastic shift to DFS would be difficult to adopt.

DEMAND SIDE INSIGHTS

Mass Market Customer perspective

This group analyzed the situation from a mass market consumer’s perspective. With respect to the use of DFS in the current scenario the participants came up with the following models:

The first participant demonstrated with the help of LEGO® blocks that the traditional payment model has been revamped with a cloud based system of online payments. This new digital utility payment system offers equal opportunity for all users thereby eliminating gender inequalities and promoting social inclusion. Virtual transfer has replaced redundancies like queuing etc. offering equal opportunities to transact.

The next model emphasized on the huge digital divide in the market and the growing number of under-represented masses. It was shown that only a small segment of the consumer market has access to ATMs and personal computers.

While portraying a simple version of person to person payments (P2P) this participant noted that currently a bulk of transactions being made through Telcos like easy paisa are from urban customers who send out cash to rural areas. These transactions have the potential to flow both ways which can be realized in the near future.

Other participants depicted how the digital financial services industry has replaced the traditional industry. With the emergence of digital channels (internet, mobile etc.) between the financial institutions and the customers’ remote banking has become common practice.

It was also shown that while the DFS space has brought convenience and ease of access through internet banking there are still areas that need improvement (for instance money exceeding a certain amount cannot be transferred through a mobile application), thereby providing opportunities for growth.

In the next round group members presented the challenges faced by users in the DFS market:

A recurrent challenge is the widening digital divide which is a huge barrier in the way of delivering products and services to the consumer. The Pakistani market is quite diverse and complex in nature with below average literacy rates and a reluctance to move away from traditional methods of doing business. Everyone agreed that illiteracy is a huge challenge where customers with poor numeracy are at a disadvantage and cannot benefit from digital financial services. A particular emphasis was laid on women who make up about half of the population but cannot access and utilize services making financial inclusion challenging. The literacy issue also hinders the arrival of new players interested in offering faster and robust services.

Another issue is the lack of collaboration and consultation between different players in DFS enablement. This disconnect can be removed with initiatives to collaborate and a willingness to work cohesively.

Another noteworthy challenge is the failure and incapability to create awareness and inform users about the products that are available for their use. The telecom sector is working in silos failing to communicate information about the products and services it has to offer.

DFS 2025 –Vision & Ideation Insights

Future of Banking Financial Institutions

While discussing the future of the financial institutions in 2025, the group gave the following input:

Banks will cease to exist in the form factor as they are today. Instead, a futuristic form of a bank will appear where cash becomes redundant and will be replaced by digital money.

There will be a rapid change from a cash based economy to a digital economy where mass market transactions will be held through mobile and e-banking, accelerating the use of DFS.

Data will be the driver of banking systems, offering need based solutions to customers. The process will rapidly enhance as the data will be connected to telecoms and banking systems simultaneously.

In 2025, there will be increased networking and connectivity between telecoms, banking institutions and data banks, leading to an overall growth in DFS. This connectivity will increase the outreach to the mass customers including women, as services will be offered based on customer behavior and patterns. Greater connectivity will also lead to investment opportunities; the group unanimously decided that by 2025, the economy will not be entirely digital but a cash based economy will still prevail.

Future of Non-Banking Financial Institutions

The group drawing on an optimistic view of the future agreed on a shared vision:

In 2025 financial inclusion will take a stride. NBFIs will take a lead role in laying out the infrastructure to realize the goal of financial inclusion.

A National Payment Gateway would be in place connecting various government entities which would have been digitized and legacy structures would have been revamped by then. The quality of services will be improved offering speed and convenience. The government will have its digital footprint all over the country.

The infrastructure will be restored and fully utilized thereby catering to a broader audience and financial inclusion to remote markets will be achieved.

In the past there were single players who had captured the entire market but in 2025 with improved coordination and no weak links, those aspiring to enter the market will have a level playing field.

Any remote entity owing to enhanced connectivity will be connected through virtual means.

Social networks (Facebook mentioned) will play a key role in connecting the customers and would play a role in facilitating payments.

Demand Side Perspective for Mass Market Customer

The group agreed that the Mass market customers will finally see the supply side players understanding the needs of the mass market segment. With customized products the mass market customers would be facilitated to join the DFS ecosystem. Some of the ideas shared included:

The first model envisioned a future scenario on a farmland where the farmer would be the owner of his land. Having surpassed all the barriers he will be able to carry out all his transactions via electronic money and distribute eco-friendly products online.

Using AI to authenticate transactions discarding the biometric system of verification. Voice recognition can also be employed to facilitate transactions.

Crypto currency would support the Digital Financial Service Industry.

More effective and efficient use of technology to offer ease of access for people with disabilities, older customers, minorities, children and women.

Building an ecosystem that supports all kinds of online financial services. The participants envisioned a future where the customer and all financial and non-financial institutions are inter connected and inter operable for everyone to utilize a service or product. There will be an online delivery and payment system and direct buying and purchasing will be obsolete. Daily transactions or payments (restaurant bills, grocery shopping etc.) will be conducted via mobile banking.

Back to the journey